Files
sure/test/models/enable_banking_entry/processor_test.rb
CrossDrain 33bc6b59c8 fix(enable-banking): import transactions missing transaction_id and entry_reference (#1767)
* fix(enable-banking): handle transactions missing transaction_id and entry_reference

Some ASPSPs omit both transaction_id and entry_reference from their transaction payloads, which is valid per the PSD2/Berlin Group spec. Previously, every such transaction raised an ArgumentError and was silently dropped during sync.

compute_external_id now falls back to a deterministic MD5 fingerprint (prefixed enable_banking_content_) derived from date, amount, currency, direction, counterparty, and remittance info. This fingerprint is stable across re-syncs, so duplicate imports are still correctly prevented. An ArgumentError is only raised for truly empty/unidentifiable payloads.

The importer is updated in three places to use compute_external_id
consistently: the pending pre-filter (before combining with booked),
the C4 stored-pending cleanup, and the new_transactions dedup. This means ID-less pending entries are now also removed when their settled booked counterpart arrives.

Tests cover compute_external_id directly (all 5 cases), end-to-end
fingerprint import, idempotency, and importer storage/dedup behaviour for ID-less transactions including the pending→booked settlement path.

* fix(enable-banking): implement dual-strategy matching for transaction settlement

When a stored pending row had only entry_reference (no transaction_id) and
the settled BOOK row arrived with a new transaction_id, compute_external_id
produced different fingerprints for each side (enable_banking_<ref> vs
enable_banking_<txn_id>). The fingerprint-only comparison introduced in the
previous commit never matched, leaving the stale pending entry in
raw_transactions_payload. Both rows were then imported as separate visible
transactions.

Restore a book_entry_refs set alongside book_fingerprints in both the
pending pre-filter and the C4 stored-pending cleanup. A pending entry is
now removed when either its fingerprint or its entry_reference matches a
booked counterpart — covering same-ID settlement, content-fingerprint
settlement, and the entry_reference cross-match settlement path.

Also updates the ArgumentError message in external_id to accurately
reflect that transaction_id, entry_reference, and content fingerprint
are all accepted identifiers, and aligns build_transaction_content_key
to use transaction_date as a fallback (matching compute_external_id).

Adds a regression test that stores a pending-only row and asserts it is removed when the booked counterpart arrives with a new transaction_id.
2026-05-12 00:17:49 +02:00

434 lines
15 KiB
Ruby

require "test_helper"
class EnableBankingEntry::ProcessorTest < ActiveSupport::TestCase
setup do
@family = families(:dylan_family)
@account = accounts(:depository)
@enable_banking_item = EnableBankingItem.create!(
family: @family,
name: "Test Enable Banking",
country_code: "DE",
application_id: "test_app_id",
client_certificate: "test_cert"
)
@enable_banking_account = EnableBankingAccount.create!(
enable_banking_item: @enable_banking_item,
name: "N26 Hauptkonto",
uid: "eb_uid_1",
currency: "EUR"
)
AccountProvider.create!(
account: @account,
provider: @enable_banking_account
)
end
test "uses entry_reference as external_id when transaction_id is nil" do
tx = {
entry_reference: "31e13269-03fc-11f1-89d2-cd465703551c",
transaction_id: nil,
booking_date: Date.current.to_s,
transaction_amount: { amount: "11.65", currency: "EUR" },
creditor: { name: "Spar Dankt 3418" },
credit_debit_indicator: "DBIT",
status: "BOOK"
}
assert_difference "@account.entries.count", 1 do
EnableBankingEntry::Processor.new(tx, enable_banking_account: @enable_banking_account).process
end
entry = @account.entries.find_by!(
external_id: "enable_banking_31e13269-03fc-11f1-89d2-cd465703551c",
source: "enable_banking"
)
assert_equal 11.65, entry.amount.to_f
assert_equal "EUR", entry.currency
end
test "uses transaction_id as external_id when present" do
tx = {
entry_reference: "ref_123",
transaction_id: "txn_456",
booking_date: Date.current.to_s,
transaction_amount: { amount: "25.00", currency: "EUR" },
creditor: { name: "Amazon" },
credit_debit_indicator: "DBIT",
status: "BOOK"
}
EnableBankingEntry::Processor.new(tx, enable_banking_account: @enable_banking_account).process
entry = @account.entries.find_by!(external_id: "enable_banking_txn_456", source: "enable_banking")
assert_equal 25.0, entry.amount.to_f
end
test "does not create duplicate when same entry_reference is processed twice" do
tx = {
entry_reference: "unique_ref_abc",
transaction_id: nil,
booking_date: Date.current.to_s,
transaction_amount: { amount: "50.00", currency: "EUR" },
creditor: { name: "Rewe" },
credit_debit_indicator: "DBIT",
status: "BOOK"
}
assert_difference "@account.entries.count", 1 do
EnableBankingEntry::Processor.new(tx, enable_banking_account: @enable_banking_account).process
end
assert_no_difference "@account.entries.count" do
EnableBankingEntry::Processor.new(tx, enable_banking_account: @enable_banking_account).process
end
end
# --- compute_external_id unit tests ---
test "compute_external_id returns transaction_id-based id when present" do
assert_equal "enable_banking_txn_abc",
EnableBankingEntry::Processor.compute_external_id(transaction_id: "txn_abc", entry_reference: "ref_xyz")
end
test "compute_external_id falls back to entry_reference when transaction_id is blank" do
assert_equal "enable_banking_ref_xyz",
EnableBankingEntry::Processor.compute_external_id(transaction_id: nil, entry_reference: "ref_xyz")
end
test "compute_external_id returns content fingerprint when both id fields are absent" do
tx = {
booking_date: "2026-03-15",
transaction_amount: { amount: "42.00", currency: "EUR" },
credit_debit_indicator: "DBIT",
creditor: { name: "Spar" }
}
result = EnableBankingEntry::Processor.compute_external_id(tx)
assert result.start_with?("enable_banking_content_"), "Expected content fingerprint, got: #{result}"
end
test "compute_external_id fingerprint is stable across calls" do
tx = {
booking_date: "2026-03-15",
transaction_amount: { amount: "42.00", currency: "EUR" },
credit_debit_indicator: "DBIT",
creditor: { name: "Spar" }
}
assert_equal EnableBankingEntry::Processor.compute_external_id(tx),
EnableBankingEntry::Processor.compute_external_id(tx)
end
test "compute_external_id returns nil for transaction with no identifiable content" do
assert_nil EnableBankingEntry::Processor.compute_external_id({})
assert_nil EnableBankingEntry::Processor.compute_external_id(transaction_id: nil, entry_reference: nil)
end
# --- ID-less transaction processing ---
test "imports transaction using content fingerprint when transaction_id and entry_reference are absent" do
tx = {
transaction_id: nil,
entry_reference: nil,
booking_date: Date.current.to_s,
transaction_amount: { amount: "10.00", currency: "EUR" },
creditor: { name: "Lidl" },
credit_debit_indicator: "DBIT",
status: "BOOK"
}
assert_difference "@account.entries.count", 1 do
EnableBankingEntry::Processor.new(tx, enable_banking_account: @enable_banking_account).process
end
expected_id = EnableBankingEntry::Processor.compute_external_id(tx)
assert @account.entries.exists?(external_id: expected_id, source: "enable_banking")
end
test "does not create duplicate when same id-less transaction is processed twice" do
tx = {
transaction_id: nil,
entry_reference: nil,
booking_date: Date.current.to_s,
transaction_amount: { amount: "10.00", currency: "EUR" },
creditor: { name: "Lidl" },
credit_debit_indicator: "DBIT",
status: "BOOK"
}
assert_difference "@account.entries.count", 1 do
EnableBankingEntry::Processor.new(tx, enable_banking_account: @enable_banking_account).process
end
assert_no_difference "@account.entries.count" do
EnableBankingEntry::Processor.new(tx, enable_banking_account: @enable_banking_account).process
end
end
test "raises ArgumentError for transaction with no identifiable content at all" do
tx = { transaction_id: nil, entry_reference: nil }
assert_raises(ArgumentError) do
EnableBankingEntry::Processor.new(tx, enable_banking_account: @enable_banking_account).process
end
end
test "handles string keys in transaction data" do
tx = {
"entry_reference" => "string_key_ref",
"transaction_id" => nil,
"booking_date" => Date.current.to_s,
"transaction_amount" => { "amount" => "15.00", "currency" => "EUR" },
"creditor" => { "name" => "Lidl" },
"credit_debit_indicator" => "DBIT",
"status" => "BOOK"
}
assert_difference "@account.entries.count", 1 do
EnableBankingEntry::Processor.new(tx, enable_banking_account: @enable_banking_account).process
end
entry = @account.entries.find_by!(external_id: "enable_banking_string_key_ref", source: "enable_banking")
assert_equal 15.0, entry.amount.to_f
end
test "includes note field in transaction notes alongside remittance_information" do
tx = {
entry_reference: "ref_note",
transaction_id: nil,
booking_date: Date.current.to_s,
transaction_amount: { amount: "10.00", currency: "EUR" },
credit_debit_indicator: "DBIT",
remittance_information: [ "Facture 2026-001" ],
note: "Détail comptable interne",
status: "BOOK"
}
EnableBankingEntry::Processor.new(tx, enable_banking_account: @enable_banking_account).process
entry = @account.entries.find_by!(external_id: "enable_banking_ref_note")
assert_includes entry.notes, "Facture 2026-001"
assert_includes entry.notes, "Détail comptable interne"
end
test "stores exchange_rate in extra when present" do
tx = {
entry_reference: "ref_fx",
transaction_id: nil,
booking_date: Date.current.to_s,
transaction_amount: { amount: "100.00", currency: "EUR" },
credit_debit_indicator: "DBIT",
exchange_rate: {
unit_currency: "USD",
exchange_rate: "1.0821",
rate_type: "SPOT",
instructed_amount: { amount: "108.21", currency: "USD" }
},
status: "BOOK"
}
EnableBankingEntry::Processor.new(tx, enable_banking_account: @enable_banking_account).process
entry = @account.entries.find_by!(external_id: "enable_banking_ref_fx")
eb_extra = entry.transaction&.extra&.dig("enable_banking")
assert_equal "1.0821", eb_extra["fx_rate"]
assert_equal "USD", eb_extra["fx_unit_currency"]
assert_equal "108.21", eb_extra["fx_instructed_amount"]
end
test "stores merchant_category_code in extra when present" do
tx = {
entry_reference: "ref_mcc",
transaction_id: nil,
booking_date: Date.current.to_s,
transaction_amount: { amount: "25.00", currency: "EUR" },
credit_debit_indicator: "DBIT",
merchant_category_code: "5411",
status: "BOOK"
}
EnableBankingEntry::Processor.new(tx, enable_banking_account: @enable_banking_account).process
entry = @account.entries.find_by!(external_id: "enable_banking_ref_mcc")
eb_extra = entry.transaction&.extra&.dig("enable_banking")
assert_equal "5411", eb_extra["merchant_category_code"]
end
test "stores pending true in extra for PDNG-tagged transactions" do
tx = {
entry_reference: "ref_pdng",
transaction_id: nil,
booking_date: Date.current.to_s,
transaction_amount: { amount: "15.00", currency: "EUR" },
credit_debit_indicator: "DBIT",
status: "PDNG",
_pending: true
}
EnableBankingEntry::Processor.new(tx, enable_banking_account: @enable_banking_account).process
entry = @account.entries.find_by!(external_id: "enable_banking_ref_pdng")
eb_extra = entry.transaction&.extra&.dig("enable_banking")
assert_equal true, eb_extra["pending"]
end
test "does not add enable_banking extra key when no extra data present" do
tx = {
entry_reference: "ref_noextra",
transaction_id: nil,
booking_date: Date.current.to_s,
transaction_amount: { amount: "5.00", currency: "EUR" },
credit_debit_indicator: "DBIT",
status: "BOOK"
}
EnableBankingEntry::Processor.new(tx, enable_banking_account: @enable_banking_account).process
entry = @account.entries.find_by!(external_id: "enable_banking_ref_noextra")
assert_nil entry.transaction&.extra&.dig("enable_banking")
end
def build_processor(data)
EnableBankingEntry::Processor.new(data, enable_banking_account: Object.new)
end
def build_name(data)
build_processor(data).send(:name)
end
test "skips technical card counterparty and falls back to remittance_information" do
name = build_name(
credit_debit_indicator: "CRDT",
debtor_name: "CARD-1234",
remittance_information: [ "ACME SHOP" ],
bank_transaction_code: { description: "Card Purchase" }
)
assert_equal "ACME SHOP", name
end
test "uses counterparty when it is human readable" do
name = build_name(
credit_debit_indicator: "CRDT",
debtor_name: "ACME SHOP",
remittance_information: [ "Receipt #42" ],
bank_transaction_code: { description: "Transfer" }
)
assert_equal "ACME SHOP", name
end
test "falls back to top-level counterparty name when nested name is blank" do
processor = build_processor(
credit_debit_indicator: "CRDT",
debtor: { name: "" },
debtor_name: "ACME SHOP"
)
assert_equal "ACME SHOP", processor.send(:name)
merchant = stub(id: 789)
import_adapter = mock("import_adapter")
import_adapter.expects(:find_or_create_merchant).with(
provider_merchant_id: "enable_banking_merchant_c0b09f27a4375bb8d8d477ed552a9aa1",
name: "ACME SHOP",
source: "enable_banking"
).returns(merchant)
processor.stubs(:import_adapter).returns(import_adapter)
assert_equal merchant, processor.send(:merchant)
end
test "builds merchant from remittance when counterparty is technical card id" do
processor = build_processor(
credit_debit_indicator: "CRDT",
debtor_name: "CARD-1234",
remittance_information: [ "ACME SHOP" ],
bank_transaction_code: { description: "Card Purchase" }
)
merchant = stub(id: 123)
import_adapter = mock("import_adapter")
import_adapter.expects(:find_or_create_merchant).with(
provider_merchant_id: "enable_banking_merchant_c0b09f27a4375bb8d8d477ed552a9aa1",
name: "ACME SHOP",
source: "enable_banking"
).returns(merchant)
processor.stubs(:import_adapter).returns(import_adapter)
assert_equal merchant, processor.send(:merchant)
end
test "uses remittance fallback for debit technical card counterparty" do
processor = build_processor(
credit_debit_indicator: "DBIT",
creditor_name: "CARD-1234",
remittance_information: [ "ACME SHOP" ],
bank_transaction_code: { description: "Card Purchase" }
)
assert_equal "ACME SHOP", processor.send(:name)
merchant = stub(id: 321)
import_adapter = mock("import_adapter")
import_adapter.expects(:find_or_create_merchant).with(
provider_merchant_id: "enable_banking_merchant_c0b09f27a4375bb8d8d477ed552a9aa1",
name: "ACME SHOP",
source: "enable_banking"
).returns(merchant)
processor.stubs(:import_adapter).returns(import_adapter)
assert_equal merchant, processor.send(:merchant)
end
test "truncates remittance-derived merchant names before persisting" do
long_name = "A" * 150
truncated_name = "A" * 100
processor = build_processor(
credit_debit_indicator: "CRDT",
debtor_name: "CARD-1234",
remittance_information: [ long_name ]
)
merchant = stub(id: 654)
import_adapter = mock("import_adapter")
import_adapter.expects(:find_or_create_merchant).with(
provider_merchant_id: "enable_banking_merchant_#{Digest::MD5.hexdigest(truncated_name.downcase)}",
name: truncated_name,
source: "enable_banking"
).returns(merchant)
processor.stubs(:import_adapter).returns(import_adapter)
assert_equal merchant, processor.send(:merchant)
end
test "uses string remittance fallback for technical card counterparty" do
processor = build_processor(
credit_debit_indicator: "CRDT",
debtor_name: "CARD-1234",
remittance_information: "ACME SHOP"
)
assert_equal "ACME SHOP", processor.send(:name)
merchant = stub(id: 456)
import_adapter = mock("import_adapter")
import_adapter.expects(:find_or_create_merchant).with(
provider_merchant_id: "enable_banking_merchant_c0b09f27a4375bb8d8d477ed552a9aa1",
name: "ACME SHOP",
source: "enable_banking"
).returns(merchant)
processor.stubs(:import_adapter).returns(import_adapter)
assert_equal merchant, processor.send(:merchant)
end
test "does not build merchant from remittance when counterparty is blank" do
processor = build_processor(
credit_debit_indicator: "CRDT",
debtor_name: nil,
remittance_information: [ "Invoice 12345" ]
)
assert_nil processor.send(:merchant)
end
end